I say thanks to the editor for stating the "disagreement" of some historians about the quote attributed to Admiral Yamamoto the Japan regarding Guns in America and why Japan walk not assault the U.S. Mainland ~ Pearl port ("Taking problem with a "gun-free society," Oct. 14).

You are watching: There would be a gun behind every blade of grass

However, upon my research before I had the quote in mine article, check out (Wikiquote.org/wiki/Isoroku_Yamamoto), that is stated, "quote was declared in a letter come Ryoichi Sasakawa before the attack" (while pointing out the details that the pending attack). The referenced "letter" is asserted to be in the extensive an individual files that Gordon W. Prange, the personal historian for Gen. Douglas MacArthur! The Yamamoto quote in this letter is claimed to be, "to invade the United says would prove most complicated because behind every blade of grass is one American through a rifle."

I did no personally search the Gordon Prange records to locate the yes, really copy the the letter when doing the research. However, logic would indicate that the letter come Ryoichi Saskakawa indigenous Yamamoto is in those files -- why make a recommendation to a particular letter"s presence -- which have the right to be showed by checking those extensive documents -- if one has actually the time and energy -- if such a details letter does no exist?

Historian Donald M. Goldstein (cited in the editor"s keep in mind as questioning the authenticity the the quote, was involved in composing a significant book around the Pearl port planning. The book is a fairly fine historical piece ~ above the subject; and also probably the many detailed. However, just since he states he "never observed the document" is much from proof the certain letter what deep in the Prange Files, does no exist. Those documents are extensive.

I believe I review somewhere, but can"t it is in sure, the Prange himself stated the Yamamoto quote indigenous time come time in conversations before he died. However the details letter reference is far an ext relevant; and also with time and also energy, an ext verifiable. ~ all, it one of two people does exist or that doesn"t. But the facts remain. Japan walk not invade the U.S. Mainland after ~ Pearl Harbor. And we were armed.

So ns stand by the Yamamoto quote, and leave it approximately the reader to determine its validity. However I personally don"t view a problem. The letter is particularly referenced. A find of the Prange papers can be done if desired. 

And the American mainland is much safer now from aggression by a international power as such fact. Ask an excellent Britain. The unified States had to administer guns weapons and also support in world War II to England because they had banned all guns, and gun ownership by the populace; years prior to the pending intrusion of your mainland by Germany.

Without those guns, England would have actually been attacked without being able to fire a shoot in me defense. The food of the war might have been changed. Your standing army of the time was meager in ~ best; and poorly equipped. Germany was on the verge the an intrusion of an excellent Britain.

See more: How To Delete A Tumblr How To Delete A Post With Notes, How To Delete Posts On Tumblr

Various reasons stopped the invasion, however, at the very least they walk have guns from the United claims to use in self defense.




capture the recent in Opinion

Get opinion pieces, letters and editorials sent directly to her inbox weekly!

* i understand and agree that registration on or usage of this website constitutes agreement to that user agreement and also privacy policy.

The Guest Editorial -- "Praise the Lord, I"ve seen the dark," by Garrison Keillor (July 24) --has taken the it is registered to a new low in so-called…