Ah the burdens the celebrity are mighty, specifically when you a famed intellectual. The course, i’m referring come myself, Buzzkillers, yet other brainiacs have suffered before me. Sigmund Freud, the founder that psychoanalysis and one of the most well known scientists of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, has actually been greatly burdened through a lot of quote attributions since his death, consisting of the “sometimes a cigar is simply a cigar” line. Together you know, Freudian analysis placed a most analytical load on the symbolic and also psychological definitions how people used and valued usual items, such together cigars and cigarettes.

You are watching: Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar meaning

Among various other things, Freud was an ext or less a smoking addict by the moment he finished clinical school. He came to be especially fond that cigars and even gradually became annoyed in social circles where smoking was frowned ~ above or wherein other males weren’t smoking. As Freud’s stature grew and also he came to be a listed professor, world noticed the his students and also medical assistants made sure to take up cigar smoking.

As ns said, countless everyday objects seemed packed v symbolism and also psychological meaning, particularly when people seem addicted to your use. Further, countless things seemed phallic to Freud. Yet did this incorporate the humble cigar?

If you room a devotee the the inter-webs and also a follower of one of the endless number of “Quote the the Day” Twitter feeds, girlfriend are encouraged by currently that Freud famously dismissed over-thinking and over-analysis by saying, “sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.” however did he ever say it?

No, Buzzkillers. But you’d it is in forgiven for reasoning that the great doctor to be the father of this quote since expert psychiatrists and also biographers the Freud claimed he was. Recommendation to this claimed Freudian quip appeared in reliable journals from the 1950s v the 1970s. Those authors often said it was a “well-known” Freudianism.

The Quote or No Quote research professionals here in ~ the Institute have actually relied ~ above the occupational of Garson O’Toole, the Quote Investigator, as well as Fred Shapiro the the Yale book of quote to conclude the there’s no proof that Freud ever said it. Once Dr. Alan Elms, a psychology professor and historian that psychology concurred in an write-up entitled “Apocryphal Freud: Sigmund Freud’s Most well known ‘Quotations’ and also Their actual Sources,” the chapter to be closed top top this renowned saying being among Freud’s.

After all, Buzzkillers, occasionally a quote is simply a no quote.

See more: Plus With A Circle Around It H The Plus Inside (⊕) Mean? What Does A Circled Plus Mean

Buzzkill Bookshelf:


*

Professor Buzzkill occasionally goes by the alias Joseph Coohill, a historian of modern-day Britain and also Ireland. In addition to his Oxford doctorate, Coohill has actually an MA in background from the college of Melbourne (where he was a large fan the Essendon Aussie rules Football Club) and a BA native Humboldt State university in California (where he to be the just non-stoner). That is the author of concepts of the liberal Party and also Ireland: a Short history (4 editions), and also many articles and internet pieces on history.