John Boyne’s novel ‘The young in the stripe Pyjamas’ was an initial published in 2006 and adjusted into a best-selling film 2 years later. The is an international best-seller and also as that 2016 it had sold 7 million copies. Teachers throughout the UK usage it together a tool to teach around the Holocaust in both background and English lessons.

You are watching: Shmuel the boy in the striped pajamas

Many people who have read the publication or watched the film adaptation think that it is a true story based on real people and also real events. However, it is crucial to understand that the book is a work of fiction. The events portrayed could never have actually happened. In this blog I rundown some the the book’s historical inaccuracies and also stereotypical portrayals of significant characters that help to perpetuate attention myths around the Holocaust.

Bruno

*

Picture credit: ew.com

Bruno is the key character in the book. He is a young German boy whose father, a high-ranking Nazi, bring away a brand-new job meaning the household have to move to a brand-new place. Bruno is ripe years old but doesn’t seem to be aware of the war approximately him, that the Jews room or also who Adolf Hitler is. Together a young German boy, and the boy of a an elderly SS officer, Bruno would have actually been, by law, a member of the Hitler Youth. He would have actually attended a German institution where students frequently swore oaths come Hitler and where antisemitic propaganda infiltrated every part of the curriculum. Kids were taught the the battle was miscellaneous to it is in proud of together it intended that Germany would come to be a great power once more.

Bruno’s characterisation perpetuates the id that most German civilians to be ignorant of what was happening roughly them. In reality the basic public in Germany and in occupied Europe were well aware that Jewish world were being persecuted, required to emigrate and also eventually deported. Over there were also many who knew that Jewish people were being killed. Countless Germans profited native the Holocaust as Jewish properties and belongings to be ‘Aryanised’, which supposed they were taken from their Jewish owners and given rather to ‘ethnic’ Germans. A decimal of German civilians withstood Nazi ideology. Nazi authorities stamped out resistance to the regime quickly and also brutally.

Shmuel

*

Picture credit: imdb.com

Shmuel is a young Jewish boy who Bruno meets whilst exploring near his new home. The an initial time lock meet, Shmuel is behind the barbed cable of a concentration camp. End the course of the story the 2 boys create a friendship despite being be separated by the barbed cable fence.

As one audience we discover a lot about Bruno, so he becomes a real little boy in ours imaginations. However, Shmuel is only ever depicted as a one-dimensional victim. Shmuel has no personality or individuality, therefore the audience doesn’t construct an emotional link with him. This means it is harder because that the leader to empathise with Shmuel and also his situation.

Shmuel’s characterisation portrays Jewish victims as passive and unresisting. However, Jewish resistance did exist both in and outside the concentration and also death camps. In ~ Auschwitz-Birkenau a group of Sonderkommando (Jewish prisoners forced to perform the destructive work of herding civilization into the gas chambers, then removing the dead bodies) successfully controlled to punch up one of the crematoria and also kill a variety of guards. The is necessary that world understand that Jewish human being did not go to their deaths there is no trying to conserve themselves.

Shmuel’s story is additionally historically inaccurate. For readers of the publication it is clear the the camp is most likely the Auschwitz concentration camp complex as Bruno calls it ‘Out-With’. If a young boy prefer Shmuel had gotten in Auschwitz-Birkenau then it is very likely that would have been sent out straight to the gas chambers top top arrival, similar to the majority of youngsters who come there, together the Nazis didn’t consider them beneficial as required labour. A small number of children were liked for clinical experimentation however these kids were maintained away from the key camp. Even if Shmuel had been selected for forced labour he would not have had actually the possibility to spend many of his days sit on the suburbs of the camp.

The Ending

The story’s conclusion leaves many readers upset. Bruno digs a tunnel under the wire, crawls into the camp, then he and Shmuel go searching for Shmuel’s absent father. Both boys space swept up in a group of detainees being required to the gas chamber, where every one of them space murdered. The emotional focus of the story is on Bruno’s family and their distress as they realise what has happened to their son. The reader’s attention stays with the endure of the concentration camp commandant and his wife whose son has actually been eliminated in what is portrayed as a catastrophic accident.

Because the focus of the story continues to be on Bruno’s family, the publication does not communicate with the main tragedy the the Holocaust: the none of the world in the gas chamber should have been there. Because of the method in i m sorry Shmuel’s character is depicted in the novel, his personality doesn’t interact the reader’s sympathy in the method that Bruno does. Shmuel represents the 1.5 million youngsters murdered by the Nazi regime in Auschwitz-Birkenau, in the death camps of lived in Europe and in the killing areas where countless civilians to be shot into mass graves, however the reader’s sympathy is directed towards a Nazi concentration camp commandant and his family.

*
Picture credit; yadvashem.ubraintv-jp.com

What are the alternatives?

Some educators will argue that ‘The boy in the striped Pyjamas’ helps raise awareness of the Holocaust in civilization who would not otherwise it is in interested, and also there is perhaps some fact in that. However, in an educational context it is important but that this publication is only supplied as a piece of fiction and that teachers make clear to young civilization that historically the publication is no factual. There are very many survivor account of the Holocaust that are obtainable to young people, or novels that are much more accurately based in fact and also less problematic from a historical and ethical allude of view, that teachers can use in the classroom. Our learning programme because that children and also young human being is based upon the life story of 16 children and young civilization who escaped or endured the Holocaust. Below are some of the different publications we imply teachers look at into.

Survivors of the Holocaust: this graphic novel through Huddersfield-based Fettle animation is based upon the real-life testimony of 6 survivors every one of whom likewise feature in the ‘Through ours Eyes’ exhibition. The book was painstakingly researched yet is obtainable for young people. The publication is based on a collection of award-winning animations created in partnership v the BBC.

When Hitler Stole Pink Rabbit by Judith Kerr: the award-winning writer and illustrator the The Tiger who involved Tea and the Mog story was born into German Jewish family who fled Germany in 1933 and also came to the UK in 1936. This semi-autobiographical book gives a childs-eye check out of the second World War.

Hitler’s Canary by Sandi Toksvig is based upon Sandi’s family experience. In Denmark the Danish populace came together and were able to conserve the bulk of Danish Jews by helping them flee to neutral Sweden or hiding them within Denmark, this is the story the one families duty in the rescue.

The Diary the a Young Girl by ann Frank is the most well known piece of composing by a victim the the Holocaust. Anne is a genuine child writing around her genuine experiences life under Nazi preeminence whilst in hiding in Amsterdam. Over there are additionally versions easily accessible that are perfect for primary school students.

Once by Morris Gleitzman speak the story the a young Jewish boy’s find for his parents. The novel is told v Felix’s eye so the atrocities that witnesses in Nazi populated Poland are told from a child’s perspective.

We have actually first-hand filmed survivor testimony on ours website that is accessible to use for free, this can be found here.

See more: How Does Voldemort Hold His Wand Like An Idiot? The Noble Collection: Lord Voldemort'S Wand

We run constant events in ~ our Exhibition & learning Centre in ~ the college of Huddersfield. Discover out what’s on and also book your ar here.