The melt Pot is a theory of American culture that class schools have been teaching for plenty of years. Metaphors typically don’t translate and they should, however I’ll shot my finest to occupational through the ideas. Ns propose that America is a social “Melting Pot.” I execute not, however, think that it is a melt pot in a hopeful sense it is definitely not one of cultural acceptance inclusion. The melt Pot to be a welcoming location for those of europe descent. They were the broth (or the base) that constituted what anyone else had to conform to. It would certainly be straightforward for one come distinguish between a broth a non-broth item. If you want to right in it is in a complete member the American culture, you hoped to come to be the broth. This can be watched within the Irish. The ireland were initially huge pieces, out of location in this melting pot. Together time walk on, however, the irish were confronted with one enticing offer. If they chose to align v the autonomous party assimilate, they would certainly be allowed to melt into the pot fully be treated as equals “white.” Their adaptation into this pot would your oppression in America enable them to insurance claim a feeling of belong in the society. The blacks, ~ above the various other, were chunks that could not it is in melted right into this pot at all. They were bones perhaps, something the one walk not want in the pot to start with. They were not intended to fit into society, simply to be provided as servants taken into consideration to it is in property. 

Gulliver native Johnathan Swift’s Gulliver’s travels is one instance of a character who travels take him to cultures that additionally conform come the melt pot model. Choose the Irish, he chooses to assimilate v the human being that he comes throughout in his travels (or at least attempts to as much as possible.) This deserve to be seen in the adoption of the custom-mades of the international that sets foot ~ above the rejection of his English identity in the process. In Zion Boucicault’s The Octoroon, however, Zoe refuses come assimilate into the melting pot of the society. Zoe is a peculiar character in the context of the melt pot—she could pass as part of the broth since of she white ancestry, however she feels together though her one-eighth black color heritage totally isolates separates her from them. Zoe refuses to leaving her black color heritage bloodline, also when available the possibility to assimilate into society through marriage. In spite of the various other character’s insistence the she might assimilate or the idea the she can “pass” as white, Zoe seems to i ordered it to the “one-drop rule.” This is an ideology that also a tiny percentage of black color heritage makes one’s identification black, or non-white. Zoe breaks societal norms by adopting this rule, quite than the usual situation of whites using it as a tool for be suppressive justification for the separation of the other. In the melting Pot, Zoe appears as though she might be broth (white), yet she sees herself as the bone (black) the does no belong. This complicates the audience’s uubraintv-jp.comerstaubraintv-jp.coming of the melt pot race in the play, calling right into question the framework of both your legitimacy.

When i was in center school, they also introduced the theory of a cultural “Salad Bowl”, suggesting that it could be a much more inclusive exact representation of exactly how America’s culture developed. Uneven the melt Pot, which is homogenous, the Salad key is a heterogeneous mixture. This heterogeneous mixture was something that us were taught to promote diversity, together it allows one to recognize the iubraintv-jp.comividual identities that added to the whole of American culture. This concept, however, was more optimistic or idealistic 보다 they realized.

You are watching: Melting pot vs. salad bowl

See more: Question: Who Determines Ethical Standards For Advertising Fast Food ? Answers

Probably the melt Pot theory is in history accurate because of how its problematic nature mirrors the problematic way in which American culture developed. Upon its analysis, it more accurately frankly addresses the injustices of the time, instead of sugar coating the in the means that the Salad key attempts.


CategoriesBecoming white, cultural Theories, Placelessness, Uncategorized Tagscultural theory, gulliver"s travels, identity, melting pot, octoroon, one-drop rule, salad bowl